Which Situations Should AC or 4-20mA Vibration Sensors Be Preffered?

<figure class="wp-block-image size-full"><img src="https://mems.com.tr/wp-content/uploads/2024/09/hansford-sensors-ac-4-20ma-vibration-sensor.jpg" alt="Hansford Sensors AC and 4-20mA Vibration Sensors" class="wp-img-9600"/></figure>

Vibration monitoring is a critical component of predictive maintenance strategies for industrial machinery. When selecting the right sensor for your application, the primary decision often lies between AC (Accelerometers) and 4-20mA (Loop Powered) sensors. Brands like Hansford Sensors provide specialized solutions for both types.

Understanding which sensor to choose depends on the complexity of the analysis required and the existing infrastructure of your facility.

1. AC Vibration Sensors (Accelerometers)

AC vibration sensors provide a raw voltage signal proportional to the instantaneous acceleration. These sensors are typically used in conjunction with a data collector or a dedicated vibration analyzer.

When to Prefer AC Sensors:

Detailed Diagnostic Analysis: If you need to perform FFT (Fast Fourier Transform) analysis to identify specific fault types such as bearing inner race defects, gear tooth wear, or cavitation, AC sensors are mandatory. They capture high-frequency data and provide a complete waveform.
Portable Measurements: If your maintenance team uses portable data collectors for periodic route-based monitoring, standard AC accelerometers with BNC or MIL-spec connectors are the industry standard.
High-Frequency Applications: AC sensors have a wider frequency response range, making them ideal for high-speed turbines or precision gearboxes.
Permanent Monitoring with External Hubs: When sensors are wired to a central vibration monitoring system (VMS) or a switch box for remote analysis.

2. 4-20mA Vibration Sensors (Loop Powered)

4-20mA sensors process the vibration signal internally and output a proportional current signal (typically representing Velocity RMS or Acceleration RMS). This signal is compatible with standard industrial control systems.

When to Prefer 4-20mA Sensors:

Direct Integration with PLC/SCADA: If you want to monitor vibration levels directly on your existing PLC, SCADA, or DCS systems without purchasing additional vibration analysis hardware, 4-20mA sensors are the most cost-effective solution.
Trend Monitoring: They are excellent for tracking the overall "health" of a machine over time. If the vibration exceeds a preset threshold (e.g., 7.1 mm/s RMS), the PLC can trigger an alarm or a machine shutdown.
Long-Distance Signal Transmission: The 4-20mA current loop is highly resistant to electromagnetic interference (EMI) and signal loss over long cable runs, making it ideal for large industrial plants.
Simple "Go/No-Go" Decisions: For auxiliary equipment like fans, pumps, and motors where a simple trend of overall vibration is sufficient to decide when maintenance is needed.

Comparison Summary

Conclusion

The choice between AC and 4-20mA sensors depends on your maintenance goals. If your priority is automated protection and simple trending via a PLC, a 4-20mA sensor is the best choice. If your goal is in-depth root cause analysis and predicting specific component failures, an AC vibration sensor is essential.

In many modern facilities, a hybrid approach is used: 4-20mA sensors provide continuous monitoring for the entire plant, while AC sensors (or dual-output sensors) are placed on critical assets for deeper analysis.

As a distributor of Hansford Sensors, we offer a wide range of industrial vibration sensors suited for any environmental condition. Contact us to determine the most suitable sensor model for your application.